After passing out at 10:01 p.m. last night (thanks Jim), we woke up looking as dazed and confused as Jason Castro. Are we in some horrible pesadilla? Did David Cook really take the crown mic as the new American Idol? It took us some time to wipe our lágrimas away but here we are with our stale chimichangas and spilt sangría feeling a little bummed that Archu didn’t take the win. We’re not sore losers though, congrats to David Cook because it sure was a close one!

Photo via Reuters